Stratos Jets - The Scott Wallace Agency
Back to All Articles
Charter Broker vs. Aircraft Management Company vs. Operator: Who Does What
Industry Insights

Charter Broker vs. Aircraft Management Company vs. Operator: Who Does What

Scott WallaceOctober 18, 20266 min readUpdated November 13, 2026

The short version

  • The operator flies the trip and holds operational control. On a charter that is the certificated air carrier, usually under Part 135.
  • A management company runs an airplane for its owner. It is the operator only on trips flown under its own certificate.
  • A broker arranges the trip and is never in operational control. Federal rules require it to say so and to use only properly authorized carriers.
  • For any quote, ask one thing: whose certificate is this trip on?
On this page
  1. Three Roles, One Airplane
  2. The Operator: Whoever Holds Operational Control
  3. The Aircraft Management Company: Running the Airplane for the Owner
  4. The Charter Broker: Arranging the Trip, Not Flying It
  5. Do You Need a Broker If You Can Book a Management Company Directly?
  6. Where Scott Wallace Agency Fits

Three Roles, One Airplane

Ask three people in private aviation who "runs" a jet and you may get three different company names. One might be the company that holds the FAA certificate, one the company that manages the airplane for its owner, and one the company that sold you the trip. All three can be legitimate. They just do different jobs, and the difference matters most on the question you care about: who is actually responsible for your flight.

The short version: the operator flies the trip, the management company runs the airplane for its owner, and the broker arranges the trip for you. Sometimes one company wears two of those hats. The rest of this post explains how to tell which hat is on for your flight.

Who does what
CompanyIts jobIn operational control of your flight?
Charter operatorFlies the trip: decides whether the flight goes, assigns the crew and keeps the aircraft airworthyYes
Aircraft management companyRuns the airplane for its owner: pilots, maintenance, hangar, insurance and paperworkOnly on trips flown under its own Part 135 certificate
Charter brokerArranges the trip for you with a certificated carrierNever

The Operator: Whoever Holds Operational Control

Federal rules define operational control as "the exercise of authority over initiating, conducting or terminating a flight" (14 CFR 1.1). On a charter, that authority belongs to the certificated carrier. The FAA's own guidance on aircraft leasing, Advisory Circular 91-37B, puts it plainly: "When chartering an aircraft, the charter air carrier has operational control and is responsible for regulatory compliance and the safety of the flight."

The same circular says no one may legally offer charter air service for compensation or hire without an FAA certificate under Part 121, 125, or 135. For most private jet charters that means Part 135. The operator decides whether the flight goes, assigns the crew, and keeps the aircraft airworthy.

The Aircraft Management Company: Running the Airplane for the Owner

Many business jets are owned by a person or a company that does not want to run a flight department. A management company handles that work for the owner: hiring and scheduling pilots, arranging maintenance, hangar, insurance, and the paperwork. When the owner flies for their own purposes under the general operating rules (Part 91), the owner normally keeps operational control. AC 91-37B notes that when a lessee operates an aircraft under the general operating rules, "the lessee accepts operational control responsibilities," and the FAA looks at who really makes the decisions, not just what the contract says.

Here is where the confusion starts. Some management companies also hold a Part 135 certificate, and the owner may let them place the airplane on that certificate to fly charter when the owner is not using it. On those trips the management company is acting as the operator, and operational control sits with its certificate. On the owner's own Part 91 flights, it does not. Same airplane, same pilots, different responsible party depending on the flight.

One warning the FAA spends real time on is the "sham dry lease," where someone is handed an aircraft on a lease while it is "actually serviced and flown by the leasing company." The FAA's Safe Air Charter page calls this a "wet lease in disguise." It is one of the ways a trip that should be a certificated charter ends up flown outside a certificate.

The Charter Broker: Arranging the Trip, Not Flying It

The DOT's air charter broker rule, 14 CFR Part 295, defines a broker as a person or entity that "holds out, sells, or arranges single entity charter air transportation using a direct air carrier" (section 295.5). A direct air carrier, in the same section, is the one "that has control over the operational functions performed in providing that transportation." In other words, the broker is never the one in operational control. Part 295 sets a few hard lines:

  • Only properly authorized carriers. Under section 295.20, a broker may not arrange charter flights on anyone who lacks the required DOT economic authority and FAA safety authority, or sell a trip the carrier is not authorized to operate in its own right.
  • Say what you are. Under section 295.23, broker advertising, including websites, must clearly state that the broker is an air charter broker, not a direct air carrier in operational control of aircraft, and that the flight will be provided by a properly licensed direct air carrier.
  • No deceptive practices. Section 295.22 prohibits any unfair or deceptive practice. Our earlier post on broker vs. operator responsibility covers the specific examples and the disclosures a broker owes you before you sign, and our Part 295 guide walks through all six.

What a broker brings is reach and judgment: access to many operators instead of one, the work of comparing aircraft and crews, and someone on your side of the table when plans change.

Do You Need a Broker If You Can Book a Management Company Directly?

You can. If a management company holds a Part 135 certificate and has the right airplane for your trip, booking with it directly is a normal, legal way to charter. The tradeoff is choice. A single operator's own aircraft are limited to what is on its certificate, so the right size, the right location, or a backup on a mechanical day depends on what that one company has available. It may arrange another carrier's aircraft for you, and if it does, ask which carrier will actually operate the flight.

If you prefer not to rely on a broker to vet operators, the checks are the same ones a careful broker runs. Get the operator's legal name and confirm it holds a Part 135 certificate. Confirm the specific aircraft, by registration number, is authorized in that operator's operations specifications (the FAA-issued list of aircraft it may fly under its certificate). Ask for a third-party safety rating, which our guide to ARGUS, Wyvern, and IS-BAO explains, and ask about crew experience and insurance. The safety page lists what we look for.

Where Scott Wallace Agency Fits

Scott Wallace Agency is an air charter broker and a Stratos Jets franchise. We do not own or manage aircraft and we do not hold operational control of any flight. Every trip we arrange is operated by a properly certificated air carrier, usually under FAA Part 135 and sometimes a management company flying under its own certificate, and we tell you which one, by legal name, before you sign. Scott is a professional pilot and flight instructor, so the operator, aircraft, and crew on your trip get a pilot's review, not just a price comparison.

If you are an owner deciding how to fly, or a traveler trying to make sense of who is behind a quote, reach out and we will walk through it with you. To price a trip, request a quote.

Common questions

Who is responsible for the safety of a charter flight?

The certificated air carrier operating it. FAA Advisory Circular 91-37B says the charter air carrier has operational control and is responsible for regulatory compliance and the safety of the flight.

Can I book directly with an aircraft management company?

Yes, if it holds a Part 135 certificate and has the right airplane for your trip. The tradeoff is choice, because a single operator is limited to the aircraft on its own certificate.

Is a charter broker allowed to operate flights?

No. Under 14 CFR Part 295 a broker arranges charter air transportation using a direct air carrier, and must state clearly that it is a broker and not the carrier in operational control.

Links and resources

Everything this article points to, in one place.

Scott Wallace
Scott Wallace
Founder & CEO, Scott Wallace Agency

Air charter broker (14 CFR Part 295) and Stratos Jets franchise owner, with a 15-year professional pilot career plus charter brokerage experience. Scott helps executives, families, and corporate clients find safe, cost-smart charter solutions worldwide.

Keep reading

Ready to Experience Private Aviation?

Get a personalized quote from Scott Wallace Agency, an ARGUS Certified broker through the Stratos Jets network. Quotes within the hour, 7 AM to 10 PM Mountain.

Request QuoteAircraft